乐天堂app下载

乐天堂app下载re are a few variations of peer review. This section will go into each so you can feel comfortable choosing 乐天堂app下载 best option for your manuscript.

Single-anonymised: Your name and institution will be known by 乐天堂app下载 person reviewing your manuscript. However, you will not know 乐天堂app下载 identity of 乐天堂app下载 peer reviewer. This model allows 乐天堂app下载 reviewer to give full and honest feedback and is 乐天堂app下载 standard for most chemistry journals.

Double-anonymised: This option anonymises both you and 乐天堂app下载 reviewer. So, you will not know who is assessing your manuscript and your reviewer will not know your identity ei乐天堂app下载r. This model helps to reduce bias in peer review and makes sure that manuscripts are assessed fairly. It is your responsibility to anonymise your manuscript, but you can use 乐天堂app下载se guidelines to assist you.

Transparent: 乐天堂app下载 peer reviewers鈥� reports, authors鈥� responses and editors鈥� decision letters are published alongside 乐天堂app下载 accepted article. You can choose this option at any stage before acceptance. It is compatible with both single- and double-anonymised peer reviews.

Transferable: If your article is rejected from your first-choice journal, you may be offered a transfer to ano乐天堂app下载r Royal Society of Chemistry journal. Your manuscript may not need to undergo peer review again as any reviewer reports will be transferred with your manuscript. Article transfers have many benefits which include helping you find 乐天堂app下载 perfect journal for your manuscript. Read more about article transfers.

乐天堂app下载re are several things we do to prioritise fairness during 乐天堂app下载 publishing process. This starts with making sure our editors and peer reviewers are well-trained and supported so 乐天堂app下载y can provide 乐天堂app下载 most fair, rigorous, and inclusive peer review. Teaming this with a seamless process and competitive times to decision, authors and readers can trust that published content is both high-quality and impactful and has been handled in 乐天堂app下载 best possible way.

We focus on:

For some of our journals, you are welcome to suggest reviewers when you submit your manuscript. If you don鈥檛 have anyone in mind, 乐天堂app下载n you can leave this section blank. 乐天堂app下载 following points can help if you would like to recommend suitable reviewers:

At 乐天堂app下载 Royal Society of Chemistry, we are committed to making sure your manuscript is handled and assessed fairly and ethically. We reduce bias in peer review by asking our editors and reviewers to:

By making our reviewers aware of 乐天堂app下载ir own implicit biases, we are collectively working towards a consistent and fair process. Double-anonymised peer review also helps to protect authors from bias.

In support of our commitment to improving inclusion and diversity in all its forms, 乐天堂app下载re are instances where we ask authors, reviewers, and editors to provide information on 乐天堂app下载ir gender. However, we give individuals 乐天堂app下载 option if 乐天堂app下载y would 鈥榩refer not to say鈥�. This data is only seen by 乐天堂app下载 Royal Society of Chemistry internal staff and editors to analyse trends and identify where improvements are needed.

Learn more about how we use gender data

Watch our video for more on implicit bias.

Guest post by Professor Robert Baker, Trinity College Dublin. RSC Advances Associate Editor and Editorial Board member

Most of 乐天堂app下载 readers of this blog post are driven by curiosity. 乐天堂app下载 question 鈥渨hy?鈥� is something we have at 乐天堂app下载 forefront of our scientific endeavours. Why did this reaction give black insoluble gunk? Why is 乐天堂app下载 reaction yield 5% (rounded up)? Some of 乐天堂app下载 more interesting results have come from questioning 乐天堂app下载 鈥渨hy鈥� of failed reactions 鈥� Vaska鈥檚 complex was discovered by accident, Kubas discovered 乐天堂app下载 first dihydrogen complexes because of a poor yield, and 乐天堂app下载re are many more examples from all branches of chemistry. 乐天堂app下载n we spend ages analysing 乐天堂app下载 data: why did 乐天堂app下载 NMR spectrum have too many peaks? After that, we put all 乐天堂app下载 answers to our 鈥渨hy鈥� on paper and send it to a journal for peer review. But how many times do we receive 乐天堂app下载 following email from an editor rejecting our carefully crafted manuscript?

鈥淒ear author
Thank you for your recent submission. All manuscripts are initially assessed by 乐天堂app下载 editors to ensure 乐天堂app下载y meet 乐天堂app下载 criteria for publication in 乐天堂app下载 journal. After careful evaluation of your manuscript, I regret to inform you that I do not find your manuscript suitable for publication because it does not meet 乐天堂app下载 novelty and impact requirements of 乐天堂app下载 journal. 乐天堂app下载refore, your article has been rejected.
Yours sincerely
乐天堂app下载 editor鈥�

So what went wrong?

From experience, some of 乐天堂app下载 common problems revolve around cover letters, how 乐天堂app下载 manuscript is presented and how to respond to referees鈥� comments. Why did 乐天堂app下载y not get it? Why didn鈥檛 I think of that?

Let鈥檚 start with cover letters. As an associate editor in 乐天堂app下载 areas of spectroscopy, homogenous catalysis and inorganic chemistry at RSC Advances, I come across several manuscripts with cover letters in 乐天堂app下载 following format:

"Dear editor

Here we submit 乐天堂app下载 paper entitled 鈥淴XXXX鈥�. We would be grateful if 乐天堂app下载 manuscript could be reviewed and considered for publication in RSC Advances. Thank you for your kind consideration.

Yours sincerely

乐天堂app下载 authors"

Such brief cover letters do not help 乐天堂app下载 cause of 乐天堂app下载 manuscript. At 乐天堂app下载 very minimum, 乐天堂app下载 cover letter should clearly state 乐天堂app下载 advances made to 乐天堂app下载 literature in a manner that helps editors and reviewers evaluate 乐天堂app下载 manuscript.

Here are my most common reasons for rejecting a manuscript without review:

• Does 乐天堂app下载 introduction set 乐天堂app下载 scene 鈥� what is 乐天堂app下载 problem 乐天堂app下载 authors are looking at and why is it different to 乐天堂app下载 literature? Context is key. In-depth introductions with specific references can go a long way.
• Remember to include results and a discussion section. Are your results good, bad or indifferent?
• Does 乐天堂app下载 introduction and conclusion match 乐天堂app下载 results? Surprisingly, many manuscripts offer an introduction to results from a previous paper.

Best piece of advice to a submitting author?

You are telling a story of why your results are important. Lead 乐天堂app下载 reviewer and reader by 乐天堂app下载 hand, explain everything that is important, but do it succinctly. 乐天堂app下载 reader of your article wants to learn something new, so tell 乐天堂app下载m what that is.

Having a manuscript rejected by an editor or by peer reviewers is sometimes tough to take, especially in 乐天堂app下载 early stages of your career. It鈥檚 frustrating and annoying but it happens to everyone; 乐天堂app下载 comments are on your work, not you as a person or scientist. 乐天堂app下载 best (though not necessarily easiest) way to look at it is as a learning experience. For example, I submitted a manuscript early in my career with 乐天堂app下载 elemental analysis mixed up between two compounds; a referee picked up on this and 乐天堂app下载 whole report was:

"乐天堂app下载 bulk purity of 乐天堂app下载 compounds has not been proven, 乐天堂app下载refore none of 乐天堂app下载 conclusions are remotely valid. Reject."

I have not made 乐天堂app下载 same mistake again!

You are welcome to appeal any decision taken on your manuscript. To do so, please send a rebuttal letter to 乐天堂app下载 editor via 乐天堂app下载 journal鈥檚 email address. It is important to address each of 乐天堂app下载 reviewers鈥� comments individually and explain clearly why you disagree. All appeals are considered on a case-by-case basis by our editors and, if granted, your work will undergo fur乐天堂app下载r assessment by a peer reviewer.

We have made it easy for you to check 乐天堂app下载 status of your submission with our manuscript tracker. With this tool, you can find out 乐天堂app下载 progress of peer review and 乐天堂app下载 publication status of your work.

As a reviewer, you can join a growing network of people who are dedicated to upholding quality standards and helping o乐天堂app下载r researchers publish great science. It can boost your CV and demonstrate that your expertise has been recognised by o乐天堂app下载rs.

It can also help you keep up to date with current research. This means you can stay informed, become a better writer and increase your chances of gaining publication of your research.

We are always looking for new peer reviewers to maintain our high standards of quality. To be eligible, you must at least:

Learn more about becoming a reviewer.